Hello from Palm Harbor, Florida, and Innisbrook, the site of the Transitions Championship! A huge thanks to Conor for his contributions the last several days, especially for holding down the fort yesterday (even golf writers needs a day off or two). If you haven’t read it already, check out the SI Golf Group’s weekly Sunday e-mail roundtable.
We touched on plenty of debatable topics, such as — Is this the beginning of more success for Watney? Is Kaymer still worthy of No. 1? What to expect from the struggling Phil Mickelson the rest of the season? Was Tiger’s Sunday 66 at Doral a sign he’s going to win soon or just one round? Did Doral deliver as a big-time event?
And, of course, the one I posed in the headline: Which young American has the best chance of becoming the next major media star?
Van Sickle: On another front, neither Watney nor Dustin Johnson are dynamic speakers or play with a lot of emotion. Johnson has that Freddie Couples nonchalance that makes him look like he’s so cool that he doesn’t even care (but of course he does). Watney went to the hat-over-the-face move after he yanked his drive into the water Saturday at 18, and a couple of nice fist pumps after putts Sunday. Kuchar and Mahan are equally nonplussed. Can any of these guys, notably D.J. or Watney, became a real media star for the public?
Herre: I think Johnson can, for the reason Gary suggests — he’s the next Fred Couples, ultra cool, calm and collected and sort of stylish in a 2011 way.
Van Sickle: And don’t forget, Jim, that D.J. has what the people want: the long ball. Who doesn’t like standing right behind a tee box when he blasts a driver? It’s awe inspiring.
Shipnuck: Johnson’s game and athleticism and looks can make him a star, but the Couples analogy is perfect; like Freddy, D.J. doesn’t really care about the hoopla and image-making. He’d rather chill on his boat.
Wei: And throw back a few Miller Lites.
Dusek: Neither Johnson nor Nick Watney is going to come across well enough on camera or give snappy-enough quotes in the media center. Both can play damn well and I’m not knocking them, but they simply don’t have that quality that demands attention.
Morfit: I could see Mahan playing to the media. In a press conference at Doral last year he started talking food and kind of went into a Food Network-announcer mode, cracking everyone up.
Wei: I agree with Cam. Mahan is sneaky good with the media. He’s sort of come into his own in the past year and become more confident in speaking situations. His caddie, John Wood, told me on Friday that he’s gotten more comfortable in his own skin, and he’s in a good place in his life (got married in January) and with his game.
…..
Mike Walker, senior editor, Golf Magazine: Dustin Johnson already has that star quality. He’s cool, he hits it a mile and fans just instinctively pull for him. But beyond D.J. and Fowler, it’s hard to imagine casual fans getting excited about Watney, Kuchar, Mahan.
DJ doesn’t need to say anything and he’s a star. Remember, he’s the Silent Assassin! Ultimately, I agree with Mike and it’ll be hard for non-golf geeks to get riled up over anyone besides DJ and Rickie, who is sneaky funny, like at Steve Marino’s house during the Honda Classic. On the golf course Rickie is much more reserved when speaking with the media.
Who do you think has enough star-quality to grab the attention of casual golf fans or even the mainstream public? Feel free to chime in on any of the other discussion points mentioned above, too!
(AP Photo/J Pat Carter)










I am hoping that this time, he or she is not American.
is it too late for Goydos? hahaha
Peter Uihlein is your next American media star.
Someone just needs to win enough. If an American starts winning somewhat consistently the media will turn them into a star pretty much regardless of their personality. But while a whole bunch of top 10′s might be nice, you need to have more then a win a year.
Just a question,
Who besides Tiger or Phil recently has been an American media star?
I agree with most of the others, probably DJ is the most likely. Perhaps Rickie Fowler might develop but we will have to wait and see.
Is Kaymer still worthy of #1? What an absurd question. In his first start after ascending to the spot, he turns in a middle-of-the-pack performance. So?
Take a peek at the rankings. Chop out Westwood (since we’ve all decided he couldn’t possibly deserve the top spot) and you’ll find that the point differential between #1 Kaymer and stand-in #2 Luke Donald is wider than what separates #2 through #10. Stats and jargon inside, he’s got a sizable lead.
Also, “can’t help but root for DJ?” I can’t stand the guy. He’s an annoying presence on the leaderboard. Attitude rubs me the wrong way. Laidback like Freddie, sure, but morose where Freddie is gleeful. Not very likable. The DWI didn’t help.
I do enjoy watching Bubba and Rickie. And Watney. And Stricker. (And, to hell with it, Tiger.) But not DJ, no way.
DJ – way to dim to be a media star. He comes off like a stoner / skateboarder, without the funny charisma that some of those dudes have.
He will probably win a major or two, but my guess is that it will need to be a post a low round from #5 position on Sunday, and watch the others collapse, vs. sleeping on a lead and then holding off a pack of challengers. (see Open, US Pebble)
+1 for Johnny Vegas.
Fowler already has the Michele Wie Celebrity Golf Star Award — lots of flash and media love but not much actual achievement at the professional level. The goofy looking clothes and Twitter will probably keep Rickie on the media watch list for a long time to come even if he never wins a golf tournament. Rickie is certainly the most easily recognized American golfer but it’s not because his clubs are doing the talking.
Is there anyone on any Tour capable of making golf history like Tiger? There’s no one anywhere close to Tiger’s 14 majors and how many wins? Tiger was whispered about in golf circles for years before he turned pro because he dominated at every amateur level. There is no man on any Tour who’s showing that level of dominance at this point in time. (Yani Tseng is showing signs on the LPGA but that’s an entirely different story).
The media can turn whoever they want into a golf celebrity. But golf history writes itself and seems to be on sabbatical at the moment.
bubba.
from your comments, you disagree, but he has the type of game that people love watching. he’s john daly without the lbs. and the other baggage.
ggg
You are absolutely right. There is no promise of dominance on the horizon….anywhere. And no doubt the media will wish to manufacture a star, regardless of the parity among any number of players of talent. It is easier to write positive or negative headlines with a star around.
Might be good to see a “villain” dominate golf for awhile instead of the hero worship of Woods like we had…someone cranky, aloof, insulting other players, short with the dumb media questions, winning everything and loving the beat-down, a foil for Johnny Vegas. Maybe we need a Tiger comeback after all because this past hero worship of Woods has turned golf into a WWE culture anyway.