http://youtu.be/UWnqIDI9Y9s
The Golf Channel’s PGA Tour coverage is, typically, something of a televisual Stepford; a precariously balanced world of stilted banter, sporting non sequiturs and avuncular asides, all of it held in place by little more than a selection of fetching tie pins, Kelly Tilghman’s endless capacity to be fascinated by shrubbery, and hairspray, lots and lots of hairspray.
By its strange, otherworldly system of values, the commentary-booth presence of Nick Faldo can be considered edgy, even exciting.
I say “typically” because every so often the imperatives of broadcast journalism demand more of the Golf Channel: substance, rigour, a narrative with which to frame to the business of watching men – to borrow Rory McIlroy’s phrase – hit a white ball around a field.
At odds with the channel’s brazenly sycophantic impulses, it’s a charge that can usually be met without casualties.
Unless, of course, you happen to be a PGA Tour minnow whose only biographical entry of note lists an arrest and three-month suspension for the possession of marijuana.
In that case, your potential value from the perspective of human interest and narrative-building far outweighs your claim to golfing fame. You are, to put it bluntly, expendable; never more than eighteen holes away from a heartfelt, character-defining interview with Kelly Tilghman.
You are background colour.
By the same reductive process that has seen Robert Garrigus designated “Recovering Drug Addict Guy” and Steven Bowditch “Recovery from Depression Guy.” Fate has declared that you, Matt Every, shall don the mantle of “Stoner Guy”.
But what if you decide not to play ball? What if you refuse to cooperate and allow those cumbersome hints (“You seem like a mellow guy.”), those heavy-handed cues (“I know that the word ‘lost’ might also be a fitting word to describe the state of your mind and game maybe about two years ago…”), to gain any purchase?
What if you shrug them off and, in defiance of all expectation, reject the mea culpa demanded of you?
You give, quite simply, the most gloriously subversive interview in the history of golf broadcasting.
Conor Nagle









Not Tilghman’s finest hour by a long shot, but I don’t get the celebration of Every either. At best he’s Jonathan Bender without the panache.
I usually like Kelly. Those interviews only become awkward when the subject of the interview does not willingly slip into the template the media wants. All media is dreadful. Sports and otherwise. They are a step above politicians and that only brings them up to sewer level.
Kelly has always been better in studio than on site
Well I think they were trying to cast him as the repentant stoner, and he just came off as a stoner instead. Both characterizations are silly though.
Maybe if we stopped playing the morality police, we could stop doing these interviews though. Rather than celebrating or demonizing them for their sex, drugs and rock and roll taste, we could just say as long as it doesn’t impact the public (DUI’s, arrests) then it’s not our business.
But really PGA tour, a 3 month suspension bc he got arrested for pot? That seems excessive
Golf channel isn’t the media. It’s an infomercial for the golf industry who air tournaments other networks don’t want. Wasn’t impressed with Every though. If he’d rather hang out with his stoner high school buddies than play golf I predict a short career.
Who said he should beg for our forgiveness???? Who do you think you are? He was asked to do an interview because he is leading the Sony Open. Not to be attacked about something that he was not even convicted of.
The courts of the Unted States of America decide who is guilty, not Kelly Tilghman. The PGA tour was way out of line to suspend the guy without him being convicted of any crime. And for all you people who want to vilify Matt Every…check yourself,I am sure you are a shitty human being. Matt Every Rules
Kelly is a professional, did great job. Made Matt squirm in seat. Yes charges were dropped after going all high school “its was not my dope it was theirs”. Matt, I have to assume is not the sharpest tool in the shed. He did himself no favors!
20 somethings that brag about and try to justify their smoking weed usually turn into 30 somethings that are embarrassed by their former selves. Grow up, you are with adults now, not Turtle and Drama (or whoever your stoner entourage/buds are)
After Every says “That’s all I wanna say about it,” Kelly’s next question is about “it.”
How about another suspension for Kelly. Remember her Golf Channel suspension because of her remarks about Tiger. Talk about ambush journelism. Kelly did not even have the courtesy of mentioning that all charges were dropped aganist everybody in the room after three weeks.
How about another suspension for Kelly. Remember her Golf Channel suspension because of her remarks about Tiger. Talk about ambush journelism. Kelly did not even have the courtesy of mentioning that all charges were dropped aganist everybody in the room after three weeks.
Very bush by Kelly imo. Could have asked the question more professionally. Did not have to phrase it arrested on drug use on national tv. i’m sure those words ambushed him. A professional would have phrased after your documented problems a couple of years ago…… she went after a reaction and got it. Go Matt and screw the political correct comments. be the one guy who continues to say what he feels.
I don’t think she should be suspended, but someone there needs to realize that was stupid (maybe we should all tweet Kelly and tell her). Why is she trying to cast Every in any light? Cover the actual facts, don’t cast it yourself. He’s saying his life is good and never went off track, yet she insists, “you were at some low point.” Who is she to define that?
What I don’t get: ok, she wants to use that moment to dig into shit, and yet she totally ignores his comment that much worse goes on out there.
Why is everyone throwing Kelly under the bus? She was just saying what someone was telling her to say through her earpiece!
Kelly did fine. Matt is clearly not particularly eloquent – and there’s nothing wrong with that. But the result is that he’s not going to be very well liked, because he’s quite simply not a likeable person. He comes across as arrogant and unrepentant. End of story.
He had a chance to clearly tell his side of the story, and he didn’t too. I feel no sympathy for him.
And his suspension for conduct unbecoming of a profession was justified. He put himself in a stupid situation. That’s his fault. These guys make millions, the least they can do is represent the tour well.
I realize that this guy isn’t the most articulate or smartest dude on the planet…but no one – including the stiff shirts on the TOUR – should give a crap whether he hangs out with people who smoke a little weed. It wasn’t too long ago that probably 75% of all caddies were druggies and alcoholics. And he’s right. We ALL probably know more people that smoke dope than people that don’t.
Tell me Kevin, what does Matt have to be repentant for? Having friends?
Thanks Conor, I think this was very insightful and well written. I presume you have read Simon Barnes (The Times, UK) who likes to write about the narrative in sport. Sport draws us in because it such a visual representation of narrative and we can all relate to the lessons it plays out.
I agree that in this instance the narrative was so clumsily and falsely constructed it was refreshing to see protagonist refuse to play his part.
I would like to hear your opinions on how far the journalists should go in trying to construct the narrative? Perhaps Tiger is a good example? He is really fighting for redemption through his golf or is he simply doing the only thing he knows how?
I think a fascinating aspect of narrative in sport is that we must take sides even in this case. Everybody is desperate to cast either the golf channel or Every as the wrong doer. In my opinion neither covered themselves in glory.
Ben, you are a fag.
Terrific comment, Ben.
So when Kelly interviews Tiger following his next round, will she bring up Thanksgiving 2009, just to see how he’s coping with it, what he learned from it? Of course not.
She overstepped by far and although Matt could have dealt with it better, the question should not have been asked and then probed further.
Maxfisher,
Actually I do think he had something to be repentant about. If you’re fortunate enough to choose to be a member of the PGA tour, which affords you an atypical lifestyle, you had better play by their rules. Every put himself in a situation that represents the tour poorly. For that, he deserved every minute of his suspension.
Tilghman is just not very good. If she was, she’d be doing network golf/sports coverage. Far from hot, but not unattractive. Doesn’t stammer. And that’s about it. Her voice is harsh and her personality – BORING. Maybe she’s got the negatives of Arnie doing something awful!
That interview is what you get when a 2nd rate on-air personality (thank god they got her out of the booth) and Jeff Spicoli sit down for a chat. She came across like she was doing an interview for Hard Copy, he came across like someone being interviewed by their parole officer.
I’ve had my doubts about this blog but this is some good writing Conor. Your descriptions of the Golf Channel and the Every interview both hit the mark. Kelly Tilghman has always been quite awful with her ridiculous, grasping attempts to create narratives. The ridiculous “Lost” segue along with “you seem like a mellow guy…let’s talk about drugs”– come on, that is the stuff of parody. As a broadcaster she has always been driven by this moronic impulse, it’s what caused her to blurt out that remark about Tiger getting lynched in a back alley.
Hello there I am so glad I found your website, I really found you by mistake, while I was searching on Bing for something else, Nonetheless I am here now and would just like to say kudos for a remarkable post and a all round enjoyable blog (I also love the theme/design), I don’t have time to look over it all at the moment but I have bookmarked it and also included your RSS feeds, so when I have time I will be back to read a lot more, Please do keep up the superb work. Nice One!
Nice blog! Is your theme custom made or did you download it from somewhere? A design like yours with a few simple adjustements would really make my blog stand out. Great!
Nice blog! Is your theme custom made or did you download it from somewhere? A design like yours with a few simple adjustments would really make my blog stand out. Great!
Hi, I do enjoy the way you have framed this specific issue plus it does. Thank you for this excellent piece and I really do agree with the idea.